Wednesday, January 18, 2006

Caught Between Iraq & A Hard Place

MISSION ACCOMPLISHED this time, right? Ah, no. As you may remember, this was the slogan that President Bush used a little over two years ago to declare that fighting had concluded in Iraq. Well, as it turned out, that back drop was no more accurate than their most recent ‘Plan for Victory’ banner which was posted behind Bush as he spoke at the Naval Academy on November 28th. Unfortunately, his newest plan was just a cut and paste job of the common doctrine and covenant that is already well known. For example, “I will only begin withdrawing troops when Iraqi troops are able, and when Iraq has freedom.”

So, how do you gauge that exactly? Fortunately for Bush, he didn’t have to worry answering that since his audiences are screened almost as much as he is, so that he doesn’t have to try and flee out locked doors when academic questions arise. As for appearing before the greater public, that’s where the photo operations unit comes in, otherwise known as “Photo Ops.” It is their job to, as Daily Show’s Senior Political Correspondent Ed Helms put it, “make the President appear to be the strong leader that he needs to be seen as.”

This is critical to the Administration at this time, with anti-war sentiment starting to spread within Bush’s own party, and now there are whispers of descent amongst the military commanders. Now to be fair, Bush and Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld say that they speak with military commanders regularly and according to both Bush and Rummy everything is fine.

Yet, not so says Representative John Murtha (D-PA), a decorated Vietnam vet who voted for the war, but has recently called for the U.S. to withdraw, since we have set ourselves up to be losers regardless of when we pull out. Murtha said that the same commanders that talk to the president also talk to him, “and what they say privately is not what they’re telling the president publicly.”

It would seem that the reason for this state of ‘flip-flopping’ on the part of the commanders is that if they publicly tell the President that “things aren’t going well or they need more troops,” they will get fired. This is not an unfounded belief since during the build up to war in Iraq, U.S. Army General Eric Shinseki told the Administration that they would need 300,000 troops to do an effective job in Iraq. However, the Bush administration did not believe him, so to show his appreciation Bush fired him for giving, no doubt, unwanted logical advice. Ironically, this is almost the exact same action that an absolute dictator would take, kind of like the guy the U.S. invaded Iraq to remove. What was his name, ah….Saddam Hussein?

So how long will it take us to defeat the insurgency and make Iraq free? The short answer: not for some time. In October, U.S. Central Commander George Casey, of the Iraq Multi-National Force, told the Senate Arms Services Committee that, “the average counter insurgency in the 20th century has lasted nine years and there is no reason that we should think that the insurgency in Iraq will take any less time to deal with.” But, the Administration continues to flaunt that if we pull out America will be less safe. Not according to retired Lt. General William Odom however, who says that our presence in Iraq is fueling the ranks and will of Al Qaeda.

Where is the war going? Right now it is hard to tell. Unfortunately our foresight into the future is about as dim as our president, due to the fact that he did not have a plan going into the war, and his only plan since has been in childish generalities. The fact of the matter is that we must first understand why we are there and what we are really fighting for. While this war has been justified as a fight of freedom vs. evil, it is not the freedom that is hated by those that we call enemies, but rather how the U.S. has used its economic and military “freedom” to treat others in the world. Bush and his pals don’t see it that way. But, then as the poet Voltaire put it "People who believe in absurdities will eventually commit atrocities."
By Kyle Joyner

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home